Tuesday, July 14, 2009

Cognitivism in Practice

For this week’s assignment, we were asked to identify how the resources and instructional strategies directly relate to the cognitive learning theories. Let me first begin by discussing how using “cues, questions, and advance organizers” correlate with the cognitive learning theories (Pitler, Hubbell, Kuhn, & Malenoski, 2007, pp. 73-85). The cognitive learning theories focus on “cognition-the act or process of knowing” (Smith, 1999). They place emphasis on how the brain builds connections using prior knowledge, experiencing specific events in one’s life (also known as episodic), and elaboration. By using word processing applications, such as expository, narrative, or graphic advance organizers, students can create connections between the information they learn in class and the information they implement through technology. For example, students who are learning about the United States of America can use expository advance organizers to develop brochures for a specific state they may be studying. This allows the students to research specific facts regarding their state, identify events that occurred within their state that influenced America, and develop an understanding of the culture of the people who live in their state. Creating a brochure will help the students to develop a better understanding of the state they chose to research. “Such tools allow students to connect new information to prior knowledge therefore students are building a larger array of information” (Robertson, Elliot, & Robinson, 2007). Another technological resource tool described by Pitler, Hubbell, Kuhn, & Malenoski, 2007, is using Kidspiration for cueing and questioning (pp.78-80). With the use of Kindspiration, teachers can exercise the students’ minds using cuing and questioning to promote higher-level thinking before, during, and after the lesson. Kidspiration also allows the students to visually connect the images they see to the information they learn. Many cognitive theorists believe that the connection of visual pictures is important for students, as they are more easily able to remember a picture or an event than words written in a text book.

Many students (and adults for that matter) struggle with summarizing and note taking. The ability to decipher what information is important and information that is less significant is a difficult task; although, Pitler, Hubbell, Kuhn, & Malenoski, 2007, suggest numerous resources using technology to enhance these skills. Many students are visual learners and cognitive theorists believe that connecting information with images is an effective way for the brain to process information; therefore, the use of Microsoft Word to aid in teaching summarization skills is effective. When using Microsoft Word to cross out insignificant information and highlight important facts, students can actively absorb and implement the use of summarization throughout their learning. Students can also become actively engaged in their note taking skills. Pitler, Hubbell, Kuhn, & Malenoski, 2007, indicate that the use of Inspiration is an effective tool for students to develop appropriate note taking skills (pp. 128-130). Students can create concept maps using Inspiration to identify important information and increase the connections they made throughout the lesson. This allows students to build on their connections to transfer information into their long-term memory. Dr. Orey, 2009, stated that “long-term memories are stored in networks of information.” Concept mapping is one way for students to develop this network of information, which will allow them to remember the information for a long time to come.

Virtual field trip tools are a great resource for students to develop a better understanding of the learning material. Especially with the lack of funding in many school districts, virtual tours allow all students to establish real life connections with the material they are learning in class. Cognitive theorists believe that by integrating multiple types of sensory, individuals are more likely to remember the information. Taking virtual tours allow students to incorporate multiple senses into their learning simultaneously. They are able to compare the information they view in their text books to the real event. Virtual tours, which reflect information learned in class, engage students and help them to build upon their knowledge. Through specific teacher questioning and the use of virtual tours, students can continue to make connections and build upon their higher level thinking skills.

Orey, M. (2009, March). Bridging Learning Theory, Instruction, and Technology. “Cognitive Learning Theories”. (Laureate, CD-ROM, 2009 release).

Pitler, H., Hubbell, E., Kuhn, M., & Malenoski, K. (2007). Using technology with classroom instruction that works. Alexandria, VA: ASCD.

Robertson, B., Elliot, L., & Robinson, D. (2007). Cognitive tools. In M. Orey (Ed.), Emerging perspectives on learning, teaching, and technology. Retrieved , from http://projects.coe.uga.edu/epltt/

11 comments:

  1. Shannon,

    Well done. Very thourough analysis of Cognitivisism and its role in eduaction today.

    So but true regarding the lack of funding for our schools today. I think as long as funding for technology stays strong, teachers have many tools that will allow students to experience new sites and sounds that they may not get to do in person.

    Virtual field trips, as you described allow students to visit a place or time that they may not otherwise get to do to funding or logistics. Making connections to outside resouces will help our students gain a greater understanding of our world and its many interactions.

    The question is...do students learn as much on a virtual field trip as they would on a real field trip? Are the connections as real and will they store the information long term as we would like them to. Are we just settling for an average education that could be made great by actually experienceing the information or site first hand? What do you think?

    Winner

    ReplyDelete
  2. I enjoyed reading your posting, especially your reference to expository advanced organizers to develop brochures. This past year one of the assignments the social studies content teacher I work with an myself had students create a brochure about the upcoming Presidential Election. As you stated these students were able to gain a better understanding of the events and issues surrounding the election. Since they all did have a basic understanding of this event to begin with the students were able to build upon their knowledge by connecting visual images and text within their finished products.

    I found this to be one of the most engaging and successful task that the students did all year. I believe that cognitive activities like these implementing a dual coding in instruction are extremely effective in learning. It is also noted when we provide these develop and design opportunities for students perform at their highest potential (Orey, 2001).

    Do you think these types of assessments create a more clear example of what our students are capable of?

    Lynda

    ReplyDelete
  3. Shannon,

    I like that you mentioned the summarizing capability of Microsoft Word. This was a function that was new to me before I read about it in our text. I feel like this will be a great benefit for those who struggle greatly with how to summarize. It will give them a chance to see many examples of summaries and how to go about doing them.

    I also agree that because of funding, virtual field trips are a great tool. To answer Winner's question, no, I do not think we are settling for an average education by doing virtual field trips instead of real ones. Virtual field trips make it possible to visit place that most students would never be able to go. For example, students would not be able to visit a real African game reserv, but they can still experience it thouht a site such as this http://www.africam.com/wildlife/index.php. Yes, it'd be great if we could visit every place that we studied, but obviously we can't do that in person, so that's were virtual field trips come in handy.

    Tanika, strongteacher3.edublogs.org

    ReplyDelete
  4. Rob,
    Funding continues to be an issue, but I agree with you that if we can continue to have technology, we can work around other funding issues. Nothing will be perfect, but at least we will be able to adapt. As for the effectiveness of virtual field trips, I think that students would benefit more from real field trips because they are actively engaging in the information. With true field trips, they are using numerous senses to take in the information, as opposed to virtual field trips where they are basically stationery and the camera takes them around. Although I find this to be the case, I think that the virtual fieldtrips are much more beneficial than textbooks. I think if we can use a combination of these tools, the students will truly benefit. The virtual fieldtrips add to lessons and help students connect the information. I think real field trips are ideal, but when you cannot take a true field trip, the virtual field trips add to the overall lesson. What are your thoughts?
    Thanks,
    Shannon

    ReplyDelete
  5. Lynda,
    I love your idea about developing a brochure for the presidential debate! I am sure the students learned a wealth of information through this activity and were thoroughly engaged and informed throughout the process, great idea! I definitely think that these types of activities help students to express their true potential. They are able to create individualized projects that represent their understanding of the material. As we learned in previous courses, these skills will continue to be used throughout the 21st century. Thanks for your response!
    Shannon

    ReplyDelete
  6. Tanika,
    I tutor a student over the summer for extended school year services, and after I read about the summarizing portion from our resources, I immediately thought of how beneficial it would be for him. I actually tried it the very next day with him, and I cannot explain how helpful it was for him to distinguish what is and is not important in a story. Using the tools to manually cross out the unnecessary information and highlight the important information was great for this student. He was able to visually identify the information as well as manually cross out and highlight where needed, using dual coding. We will continue to practice summarizing, and I am certain that this will help him to develop those essential skills.

    You made a great point about virtual fieldtrips and allowing students to experience places that are impossible to physically visit. I feel that it would be "settling" if schools were to completely take out real field trips and replace them with virtual field trips. For example, the fourth grade students at my school take a field trip to the Statehouse. I was able to have the students preview the Statehouse using a virtual tour, but I feel that they learned significantly more from walking around and experiencing it for themselves. I would be disappointed if they took away the real field trip and replaced it with a virtual one. On the other hand, I definitely agree that for field trips that are not feasible, the virtual field trips add a lot of information for the students.
    Thanks,
    Shannon

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hi Shannon,
    I enjoyed reading your post about cognitive theory and technology and their implication in teaching and learning.

    I particularly like the part where you talk about developing students' higher level thinking. The observation I have with my students here in HK is that they can recite a lot of facts but when it comes to thinking on their own or brainstorming ideas. They are usually stuck. They look at you with their eyes wild open and tongue tied. They are too used to someone spoonfeeding them with information or most of the time facts for them to actually think for themselves or on their own.

    This I have to admit is a very challenging task. I was the class teacher last year and it literally look me a year to try and change their mentality, not much success at the beginning but they are getting slow but gradual improvement. (And I mean *slow*). So I completely agree with you that higher-order thinking is so essential in nowadays' society that students can't do without. They might not realize that since they are all so exam-oriented, but as their teachers, we have to train them in this respect.

    Talking about virtual field trips, I also believe that it's the second best compare to real field trip. As everybody was saying budget cut, it is a real life situation that we are all facing. Virtual field trips provides students the opportunity to take on the tour anywhere anytime for as long as they like. This is something real field trips cannot do. Having said that real field trips engage students in all their senses but virtual ones only engage them visually (some of them might have the listening session included, I don't know) but the benefit of it is since it's technology, students can revisit the tour for as many time as they like to consolidate their findings and understandings. Another great benefit that real field trips cannot offer is the fact that we can take students back in time with virtual field trips. They can visit places and time dimension before they were born! This is something very powerful and nothing can beat that.

    Again thanks for your sharing!

    Sarah

    ReplyDelete
  8. Shannon,

    Yes, it's settling if we replaced real field trips all together with virtual field trips. I think that if we continue to pair the two together, the students will continue to benefit from them. Also, I'm glad that you are able to use the material from our class. I think a class is only beneficial if you can actually use the different ideas that is presented to you. Hope that it continues to go well with the student you are tutoring.

    Tanika

    ReplyDelete
  9. Sarah,
    Thank you for your response. It is true that students need to be exposed to higher-level thinking at a young age so that they can continue to develop it as they go from grade to grade. I have similar problems with many of my students where they look at you to find the answer rather than trying to use their minds to figure it out.

    You made a great point about being able to revisit virtual field trips. That is very true and often times, we need to review information more than once in order for it to sink in, so there are definite benefits to a virtual field trip in that aspect as well. I agree that being able to go back in time is a wonderful opportunity. Thank you for expanding my thoughts on virtual field trips!
    Thanks,
    Shannon

    ReplyDelete
  10. Tanika,
    I agree that if we continue to use virtual field trips in combination with true field trips, it will allow the students to experience a lot more than just reading text books or listening to lectures. I really like the additional benefits of using virtual field trips that Sarah discussed as well: viewing them more than once and being able to go back in time. And yes, I do agree that information is beneficial when you can see a use for it. So I was really happy to learn about that.
    Thanks,
    Shannon

    ReplyDelete
  11. Hi Shannon,
    I've also learned a lot from this week's reading and our experience with virtual field trip and concept mapping. Likewise I've learned a great deal of insight about cognitive tools from our blog interactions.

    Higher level thinking indeed needs to be trained and modeled at a very young age. When I get my students they are already old enough to form their own perception and thoughts that teaching them how to think is already too late. OK maybe I shouldn't say 'too late' but it's definitely very difficult to try to change their mentality.

    Sarah

    ReplyDelete